Anna Calvi and Peaky Binders director Anthony Byrne..jpg

Anna Calvi On Scoring Peaky Blinders: "Watching Cillian’s Performance, It Felt Like A Dialogue Between Us"

By order of the Peaky Blinders – or rather, a hopeful request on the behalf of the hit BBC show’s season five director, Anthony Byrne, singer-songwriter Anna Calvi was tasked with creating an original score for the brutal gangster drama’s new series. Speaking to Headliner, Calvi reveals how she got in the mindset of unbalanced and murderous main character, Tommy Shelby, and why being an outsider makes her a typical ‘Peaky’ artist.

“I remember being at school, and I wouldn’t even sing a line in a school play – I was so phobic of singing,” admits Anna Calvi. Ironically, the talented singer and musician would go on to make a living using her operatic, contralto voice – most recently being asked to write the score for season five of BBC hit show, Peaky Blinders. “I think if the younger me knew what I’d end up doing as a career, she’d be very happy, but surprised. I think out of everything I've done, overcoming my fear of singing and becoming a singer is the thing I’m most proud of, and is my biggest achievement.”

A successful artist in her own right and with a handful of Mercury Prize and British Breakthrough Act-nominated albums under her belt, composing an original score for film or TV was completely new for Calvi:

“I’ve written music for an opera before, but I’ve never done a score for a film or anything, so yeah, it was a new territory for me. It was a bit daunting at first, but it was really fun and exciting to do a take on that challenge. I’ve always been a fan of Peaky Blinders, and especially the way that they use music in a series. I think it’s used to a really amazing effect. The director, Anthony Byrne, had come to a few of my shows, we got chatting and then he asked me to do it. I was really excited to be part of it.”

Speaking to Headliner on the phone, Calvi speaks in a small, quiet voice that belies her intense, charged onstage performances. This is where her inner show-woman steps into the spotlight: On-stage, Calvi is an electric tangle of dark hair, smudged black eyeshadow and thunderous rock and roll.

For the uninitiated, Peaky Blinders is a brutal gangster drama set in the lawless streets of 1920s Birmingham, where the Shelby family fight (literally) to navigate the worlds of illegitimate and legitimate ways of empire-building – anyone opposing them swiftly finding out what is stitched inside their infamous caps.

Season five sees head of the family, Tommy Shelby (Cillian Murphy) enter the realm of politics in the midst of the 1929 financial crash. At once a war hero and an anti-hero, a troubled Shelby is increasingly succumbing to the effects of PTSD. With the weight of the world on his angry shoulders, his confident exterior rapidly gives way to paranoia, madness and suicidal actions.

“Me and Anthony talked a lot about Tommy’s psyche, and how to express what’s going on inside him,” Calvi explains. “He’s trying to portray this image that he is strong and that he’s taking care of everyone, but inside there is this dismantling of his-self that’s happening, and that’s the part I found interesting to score. [Murphy’s] performance, and the dialogue are so strong – that’s all I needed. It’s a bit like playing music with someone, where you’re watching his performance and responding to it; it felt like a dialogue between us, even though I’d never met him or spoken to him.”

It’s a bit like playing music with someone, where you’re watching Cillian’s performance; it felt like a dialogue between us. Anna Calvi

Before sitting down to score the new series, Calvi intentionally did not binge-watch the entire show as a refresher: “I specifically didn’t, because I didn’t want to get influenced by the music that had come before. Although I had watched it a while ago, I wanted to go in fresh and make sure that I did music that was for me, not what I thought they would want.”

With the daunting task ahead of her, Calvi was sent the new episodes (sometimes not finished edits) with just the dialogue captured: “In the practical sense, I would have the episode on my computer, with the dialogue. As I was watching, I’d have my guitar and vocal mic, and I would be responding instinctively to what was happening – that’s how I began the process of writing, and then I would go back and sculpt it.”

Anyone that has seen any of the season’s deleted scenes will know how strange they sound without music. “It is odd, and it kind of makes you realise how much it affects what you watch,” agrees Calvi. “The music underneath has a really big influence over what you are watching.”

Being new to the process, Calvi took a month to produce the score for episode one, but quickly got into the swing of things.

“The first episode took the longest, but as I went on, I got quicker. I think it was becoming more like a week per episode. They would have deadlines because they would need to colour it and do the sound effects, and that’s new to me too. With my own music, the deadline is basically my deadline, whereas this time, so many other people are working on it, so you can’t be the one to be like: ‘Oh, I need an extra week’. It was like having a proper job and going: ‘Shit, actually, there is a deadline!’ [laughs]. So there were a few all-nighters that I had to do to get everything done!”

It was very important to Calvi to capture the initial, emotional response that the images and dialogue gave her, sitting at her laptop with just a guitar and a Neumann U67 mic. “That’s all I need really, it’s pretty basic!”

Speaking about her 2018 album, Hunter, Calvi expresses that she wants to go beyond gender – not wanting to have to choose between the male and female in her. “I believe that gender is a spectrum. I believe that if we were allowed to be somewhere in the middle, not pushed to the extremes of performed masculinity and femininity, we would all be more free.”

With Shelby’s mental state in decline and as the calculated violence ramps up, through the score Calvi wanted to give his character a subconscious feminine voice to further unnerve viewers.

“The interesting thing about Tommy is that you fall in love with someone who is multifaceted, and not just one thing. There’s a lot of complexity to the character, and so I felt like I wanted to bring out some of this side of him – whatever feminine means, because to me, feminine in his case is his darkest and most twisted side. There’s a complexity to that that I find really interesting.”

Season five saw Shelby cousin, Michael Gray make power moves of his own, seemingly turning against the Peaky Blinders. “The interesting thing is the idea about whether or not Tommy can trust him,” says Calvi. “There was one point where I was watching the episodes with Anthony and I said: ‘Is he telling the truth?’ And Anthony didn’t want to tell me whether he was, because he liked the idea of me not knowing either. The idea with the music was to leave that open, because even I don’t know. There’s a sense of unease about that.”

As source material, season five has given Calvi a lot to play with. Complicated narratives, quotable one-liners, and cunning plans that would put Baldrick to shame play out against a smorgasbord of ostentatious ‘20s glamour and opulence. The gang are out of their depth in high society, trying to pass themselves off as upstanding members of the community, however, the inevitable pull of violence, power struggles, turf-wars and revenge are never far from their minds. “We all try and get away, but we never do,” warns the gravel-voiced head of the family, Polly.

There is music that feels ‘Peaky,’ and I think I am one of those artists that is a Peaky artist.

Before the programme aired, the ominous trailer gave audiences a peek at what was to come: Calvi and David Byrne song, Strange Weather (written by Keren Ann) perfectly accompanies slow-mo shots of the exquisitely-dressed gang, who are ready for another war.

“I think when Anthony was trying to find the right song for the trailer, that song really stuck out for him because of the beauty and danger, romanticism and also something edgy, so I think it works really well,” she says, humbly.

Calvi has often been described as a virtuoso guitarist, and is noted for her particular style of playing which involves hitting the strings in a circular motion. Her distinctive style permeates the entirety of the new series, complementing the rebellious rock and rock soundtrack synonymous with the Peaky world.

Often using high levels of reverb, the score is all woozy electric guitars, dissonant chords and distorted riffs – and full on rock and roll – heightening the sense of unease and conflict amongst the characters.

Key score moments include a beautiful melody juxtaposing a particularly violent (even for him) Arthur Shelby beatdown, and a tense assassination attempt where the guitar is strung out like the viewers’ nerves.

“The characters have different musical scenes,” says Calvi. “For Tommy it is very much about trying to express his inner world, so I used my breaths a lot to underpin the idea that he may be saying one thing, but inside there’s a turmoil and an anxiety in him which he is trying to hide – that was an important one.

"I guess what was interesting was using the guitar to express the outward side of him where he gets reckless and dangerous, but there are also elements of music which are actually moments of intimacy between Arthur and Tommy where it’s showing something more vulnerable – I guess more delicate, sad and beautiful. Those parts are actually the most fun to score because that’s when you really fall in love with a character, when you see them at their most vulnerable.”

Peaky Blinders is consistently brilliant at marrying modern music to a period setting, using artists such as Black Sabbath, Bob Dylan, Johnny Cash, Black Rebel Motorcycle Club, Davie Bowie, Radiohead, Arctic Monkeys, PJ Harvey, The White Stripes, and of course, Nick Cave in its soundtracks.

What is it about these that makes them sound ‘Peaky’? Apparently, it’s all down to being a bit of an outsider.

“Yeah, and a sense that the character and the music is an anti-hero,” she confirms. “It’s a sense of yearning and longing for something that maybe you’ll never get, but you’ll push yourself to the edge to get it. [The director] decides if it’s a ‘Peaky song,’ or ‘Peaky music’. Sometimes Anthony would ask me what I thought when they chose music for certain scenes, but I don’t get involved with choosing them.”

The show’s distinctive theme tune, Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds’ Red Right Hand very much sets the musical tone for the programme’s soundtrack, so did that consciously or unconsciously affected the process of creating the score?

“Not really, because I wouldn't be writing from that perspective – I’m really just interested in telling the inner story of the characters,” Calvi answers. “If that required it to be synth-driven, techno music, I would do it. It’s just whatever the character needs, that’s where it comes from.

"I think separate to Peaky Blinders, Nick Cave is a really important artist for me in terms of my development as a musician, so I feel he’s in me somehow anyway. The songs in the show work really well – there is music that feels ‘Peaky,’ and I think I am one of those artists that is a Peaky artist. Whatever songs that they chose, they naturally seem to work well against the score that I've done.”

Looking at other current shows, Calvi thinks the music in Stranger Things is cool: “They’ve got good music in that, that would be a fun one to do. With Peaky Blinders 5 finishing in late September, would Calvi consider doing other score work in future?

“Yeah, definitely; I loved doing it and I love the way it’s not about me. It’s about serving another purpose, and that’s really liberating – especially when you’re a solo artist and you’re always having to talk about yourself and think about your inner thoughts. It's really nice to have another perspective; it’s freeing as a musician.”

Read this interview in Headliner Magazine.

Words Alice Gustafson